Work and Pensions Secretary IDS had already ducked questions in the Commons by choosing not to speak, instead putting forward his deputy Esther McVey
IT was the day the Nasty Party showed its true-blue colours – by sneering at the plight of hungry families forced to rely on food banks. Tory MPs laughed and jeered as they were told how some hard-up shoppers were so desperate they fought to snap up discounted items in supermarkets.
Astonishingly, all the Government ministers from the responsible departments – including Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith – sneaked out after just an hour of the crucial Commons debate.
By then a cowardly IDS had already ducked questions, putting forward his deputy instead.
In one of the most shameful episodes ever witnessed in Parliament, Tory backbenchers sniggered and hooted as Labour MP Fiona MacTaggart told of shocking scenes at her local Tesco in Slough, Berks, as people battled over cut-price fruit and veg. She said the store had now been forced to draft in extra security.
Almost drowned out by mocking Tory MPs, she asked: “Isn’t that a shocking sign in the 21st century?”
Senior Labour politicians later described the Tories’ callous reaction as “shameful” and “a total disgrace”.
Labour MP Jamie Reed said: “I regret to say the laughter from the Government benches says more about this issue than words ever could.” His colleague Barry Gardiner said it was “extraordinary” to see Mr Duncan Smith smirking as it was pointed out that half a million people are now using food banks.
And The Trussell Trust, the nation’s largest provider of food banks, said it was “disappointed” by the attitude of those who jeered.
Labour had called the debate after nearly 150,000 people signed a petition
backed by the Mirror, the Unite union and The Trussell Trust
calling for an inquiry into the growing dependence on food aid.
But Mr Duncan Smith refused to answer for the Government, leaving it to his
deputy, Esther McVey.
And in an ill-judged speech, she sparked fury by claiming it was a good thing
that more people were turning to food banks.
Incredibly she insisted: “It is positive that people are reaching out to
support other people.”
She went on: “In the UK it is right that more people are going to food banks
because as times are tough, we are all having to pay back this £1.5trillion
debt personally. We are all trying to live within our means, change gear and
make sure that we pay back all our debt.”
Labour veteran Sir Gerald Kaufman
described her speech as the “nastiest” he had heard in his 43 years as an
MP.
Labour’s Lilian Greenwood added: “They are the nasty party through and
through. She doesn’t get it and won’t take responsibility.”
Shortly after Ms Mcvey’s performance, Mr Duncan Smith
scurried from the chamber, followed by an number of other senior Tories.
Speaker John Bercow said he had no power to stop them, but said the view that
it was a disgrace there was no minister there “may be widely shared”. Shadow
Environment Secretary Maria Eagle said the increasing need for food banks was a
damning indictment of Government policy.
She added: “Since April this year more than 500,000 people have relied on
assistance from the 400 food banks run by The Trussell Trust charity, double the
number of food banks compared to this time last year.”
She added: “It’s a
scandal which is getting worse and the Government now has the humiliation of the
Red Cross helping to collect and distribute food aid in Britain for the first
time since the Second World War.”
Former Labour Cabinet minister Paul Murphy told the Commons he had never seen
such poverty in his 40 years as a Welsh politician, apart from during the 1984
Miners’ Strike.
Shadow
Work and Pensions Secretary Rachel Reeves told the House: “It’s a tale of
two nations – tax cuts for the rich, food banks for the poor.”
Not all Tories joined in the mocking and jeering.
Wycombe MP Steve Baker gave an emotional speech in support of food banks as
he revealed how poverty had caused the break-up of his family when he was a
child.
He said there was no one to help when his self-employed dad ran out of work.
They had to go hungry and his parents eventually split up.
He blamed the current plight of hard-up families on politicians pretending
there is a “magic wand” to solve the problem.
Mr
Baker said 12,000 children in Buckinghamshire were currently living in
poverty, with one in five in his constituency going to bed hungry, rising to
one in three in some areas.
He added: “It is a scandalous indictment of the safety net that is the
welfare state.”
But Tory and Lib Dem MPs banded together to defeat Labour’s motion, calling
on the Government to reduce dependency on food banks, by 294 votes to 251, a
majority of 43.
Read more...
